Maybacks Pizzeria

4.3 ( 439 reviews )

Checking... 9:30 AM - 9:00 PM See Hours

3035 Genesee St #7, Buffalo, NY 14225, United States

+1 716-893-3383

Maybacks Pizzeria, located at 3035 Genesee St in Buffalo, NY, offers a delightful throwback to traditional pizza flavors that resonate with long-time fans of the genre. Customers rave about the distinct taste reminiscent of classic Pizza Hut, capturing a nostalgic experience with each bite. Reviewers like Kevin Josa appreciate the fullness of flavor, noting room for improvement in cheese and pepperoni options.

The wings have garnered high praise, with critics like Josa rating them a solid 4.5 out of 5, thanks to their generous portions and delicious sauces. Notably, many patrons highlight the subs, described as “elite” by Andrew Anable, who calls them a culinary force in their own right. The consistent quality and reasonable prices make Maybacks a go-to for both pizza enthusiasts and those seeking hearty sandwiches.

Overall, Maybacks Pizzeria excels in delivering flavorful dishes that evoke warm memories, ensuring satisfaction with every visit. Their commitment to customer feedback, such as offering a San Marzano tomato sauce, shows their willingness to evolve while serving classic comfort food. Whether you're craving pizza, wings, or a delicious sub, Maybacks is truly worth a visit in Buffalo.

Accessibility
- Has wheelchair-accessible car park
- Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Service options
- Has no-contact delivery
- Offers delivery
- On-site services available
- Offers takeaway
- Serves dine-in
Popular for
- Popular for lunch
- Popular for dinner
- Good for solo dining
Offerings
- Serves comfort food
- Serves late-night food
- Quick bite
- Serves small plates
Dining options
- Serves breakfast
- Serves lunch
- Serves dinner
- Has catering
- Has counter service
- Serves dessert
- Has seating
Amenities
- Has toilet
Atmosphere
- Casual
Planning
- Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
- Accepts credit cards
- Accepts debit cards
- Accepts NFC mobile payments
- Accepts SNAP/EBT
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs available
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
- Plenty of parking

Kevin Josa

Jun 25,2025

It's like eating pizza hut from thirty years ago when pizza hut ruled the pizza game. Just needs a bit more cheese and a cup and char pepperoni!! Tasted like the Wings used baby ray garlic parm sauce which is a great sauce. They give blue cheese and celery nice added touch Good sized wings as well 3.6 outta 5 overall on pizza . 4.5 outta 5 on wings overall. . Def recommend and will be back . Also please think about adding a san marzano tomato sauce as your base. You can thank me later. Follow these steps and I guarantee you will be tops in Buffalo in the pizzeria game. Will change to higher score if improvements are made.

David Hartzell

Jun 1,2025

The subs here are GREAT! Maybacks has a tradition in Buffalo of making excellent subs and sandwiches, and the Genesee St. Location doesn't disappoint. Yum!!

Ashlee Clause

May 30,2025

I prefer a bit more saucy but I wasn't the one who ordered. These were just what I was craving. Cannot beat the price either. Edit: Got my super saucy wings(it was at the bottom) and they were so good. Pizza was nice and cheesy! So so good!

Dominic Law

May 21,2025

Pizza was so good had so much meat! Left me satisfied and couldn’t walk for a few days after

Andrew Anable

Apr 21,2025

We have gotten Mayback's pizza and wings before and they are very good. I like their white pizza in particular. We decided to try their subs and let me tell you they are on a whole other level. They are absolutely elite. I love Dibella's but I think Maybacks subs are the current sub to beat. Every single bite is incredibly flavorful. We have gotten them a few times and they are very consistent. Above all else, the prices are very reasonable. If you want a delicious sub that doesn't break the bank, this is the spot to go. I'm not kidding when i say I would ride into battle for these subs. If these subs have no fans then I am dead. If it came down between choosing these subs over the human race... well... it's been real everybody. 10/10 will get again.

Bucky Larson

Mar 22,2025

I only eat my pizza from the back back back, but I've never been fed before before before. Usually there's a stretch stretch stretch, but the grease really helped helped helped. Only 3.50 for the fentanyl topping topping topping. Next time I'm bringing the wife and kids kids kids.

Kimmie P

Mar 16,2025

I am OBSESSED with their steak sub!! It is SO delicious. I crave it all the time and have been ordering it at least 3 times a month or more haha. They always follow directions and make it exactly as I ask for it. There was only one time that my order was missing something, but other than that they have been great.

SnowDownOreo

Mar 10,2025

I love this place but when I tried to go to the bathroom yesterday there was man being water boarded in oil again in the bathroom. THIS IS THE FIFTH TIME!!! CAN A GIRL GO TO THE BATHROOM FOR ONCE!!! ?? Let me pee!!!(And NO, not on the man this time!)

Maybacks Pizzeria

Amenities and More

Photos

Reviews For Maybacks Pizzeria

Add a Review

Location

Appreciated by Others